Menu

Menu

From the Grill - Paninis

Italian Cheese Melt

Salami, Pepperoni, thin cut Ham off the Bone, Mayo and Mustard with your choice of Cheese on Sourdough Bread. Cooper, Provolone, Hot Pepper or Bruschetta Jack

  • $9.00Sandwich & Pickle
  • $11.00Sandwich, Pickle, Chips or Cold Salad

Ham & Cheese Panini

Served on Rye or Sourdough. Mayo and Mustard with your choice of Cheese. Cooper, Green Onion, Bruschetta Jack, Baby Swiss, Hot Pepper or Sharp Yellow Cheddar

  • $8.00Sandwich and Pickle
  • $10.00Lunch includes Pickle & Chips or Small Side Cold Salad

Turkey & Cheese Panini

Served on Pumpernickel or Sourdough. Mayo and Mustard with your choice of Cheese - Cooper, Green Onion, Bruschetta Jack, Baby Swiss, Hot Pepper or Sharp Yellow Cheddar

  • $8.00Sandwich and Pickle
  • $10.00Lunch includes Pickle & Chips or Small Side Cold Salad

Grilled Cheese Panini

Featuring our Amish Cheeses front and center. Pick 2 Cheeses. Muenster, Green Onion, Bruschetta Jack, Hot Pepper or Horseradish on Sourdough or Pumpernickel Bread

  • $6.50Sandwich & Pickle
  • $8.50Sandwich, Pickle and Chips or Cold Salad

Troyer Premium Hot Dog

Grilled on our press and served in a Hot Dog Bun. Toppings are Mayo, Mustard, Ketchup, Onions, Sweet Relish and Dill Relish

Add Sweet Red Pepper Relish 0.50¢

  • $3.50Hot Dog
  • $5.50Hot Dog and Chips or Cold Salad
  • $1.00Add Cole Slaw or Sauerkraut
  • $2.00Coney Island Style Meat Sauce and Shredded Cheese

Cold Salads

Amish Potato Salad, Amish Southern-Syle Potato Salad or Cole Slaw - Sweet & Creamy or Amish Macaroni Salad


Cold Sandwiches

Turkey & Cheese

Troyer Turkey sliced thin with your choice of Cheese - Provolone, Green Onion, Cooper, or Sharp White. Thick White, Pumpernickel or Sourdough Bread. Mayo, Mustard, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Pickles, Vinaigrette, Salt & Pepper. Toasted or cold

  • $8.00Sandwich & Pickle
  • $10.00Sandwich, Pickle & Chips or Cold Salad

Ham & Cheese

Delicious Ham off the Bone sliced with your choice of Cheese. Baby Swiss, American, Cooper Cheese, Mild Cheddar, Green Onion or Hot Pepper. Thick White, Rye or Sourdough Bread. Mayo, Mustard, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Pickles, Vinaigrette, Salt & Pepper. Toasted or cold

  • $8.00Sandwich & Pickle
  • $10.00Sandwich, Pickle & Chips or Cold Salad

All American Beef Bologna & Cheese

1959 Troyer Beef Bologna sliced thin with your choice of Cheese. American, Cooper, Mild Cheddar, Sharp White or Hot Pepper. Thick White, Pumpernickel or Sourdough Bread. Mayo, Mustard, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Pickles, Vinaigrette, Salt & Pepper. Toasted or cold

  • $8.00Sandwich & Pickle
  • $10.00Sandwich, Pickle & Chips or Cold Salad

Cheese & Veggie

Our incredible Amish Cheeses - your choice of Sharp White, Baby Swiss, Mild Cheddar, Cooper, Hot Pepper, Green Onion, Muenster. White or Sourdough Bread. Mayo, Mustard, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Pickles, Vinaigrette, Salt & Pepper. Toasted or cold.

  • $6.00Sandwich & Pickle
  • $8.00Sandwich, Pickle & Chips or Cold Salad

Cheese Shoppe Specialty Sandwiches

Our Troyer Corned Beef & Pastrami Makes These Two Classics Even Better!

The Reuben

Corned Beef, Swiss Cheese, Sauerkraut with Thousand Island Dressing on Marble Rye. Toasted or Pressed (Panini recommended.)

  • $9.00Sandwich & Pickle Only
  • $11.00Sandwich, Pickle & Chips or Cold Salad

The Rachel

Pastrami, Swiss Cheese, Sauerkraut with Thousand Island Dressing on Marble Rye. Toasted or Pressed (Panini recommended.)

  • $9.00Sandwich & Pickle Only
  • $11.00Sandwich, Pickle & Chips or Cold Salad

The "LW" Cuban

Ham and Shredded Roasted Pork, Swiss Cheese, Garlic Aioli Mayo, Mustard, & Dill Pickles - pressed on a 8-lnch Hoagie

  • $9.00Sandwich and Pickle
  • $11.00Lunch includes Pickle & Chips or Small Side Cold Salad

Shopping Cart

×

Your cart is empty.