Menu

Menu

Grilled Panini-Style Sandwiches

Featuring Troyer’s Amish Meats & Cheeses!

Create Your Own Signature Sandwich with Your Choice of Bread, Cheese, Veggies & Condiments!

Sandwich Options:

  • Breads: Tuscan White, Marble Rye, Sourdough, Pumpernickel or Wrap
  • Cheeses: American, Cooper (Sharp American), Sharp or Mild Cheddar, Provolone, Baby Swiss, Aged Swiss, Lacey Baby Swiss, Amish Butter, Muenster, Green Onion, Bruschetta Jack, Hot Pepper, Desert Fire.
  • Condiments: Duke’s Mayo, Yellow, Dijon, Honey & Spicy Mustard, Pink Salt or Black Pepper
  • Veggies: Lettuce, Tomatoes, Pickles, Onions, Pepperoncinis, Jalapeños or Banana Peppers
  • Dressings: Italian, Balsamic, Oil & Vinegar, Raspberry Vinaigrette, Ranch or Thousand Island
  • Premium Aiolis: Jalapeño, Pesto, Everything or Bacon - an excellent add on - .50¢
  • Cold Side Salads: Southern Amish Potato Salad, Southern Macaroni Salad or Amish-Style Cole Slaw

Add a bag of Kettle Chips to any sandwich order for $1.49 – all flavors!

Troyer Turkey & Cheese

Pairs great with Green Onion Cheese.

  • $10.25Sandwich & Pickle Spear
  • $12.50Sandwich, Pickle Spear & Cold Side Salad

Troyer Ham & Cheese

Pairs great with Baby Swiss on Marble Rye.

  • $10.25Sandwich & Pickle Spear
  • $12.50Sandwich, Pickle Spear & Cold Side Salad

All American Beef Bologna & Cheese

Awesome on Tuscan White & Cooper Cheese.

  • $10.25Sandwich, Pickle Spear
  • $12.50Sandwich, Pickle Spear & Cold Side Salad

Troyer Cajun Turkey & Cheese

Flavor Town - add Hot Pepper Cheese for some kick.

  • $10.25Sandwich, Pickle Spear
  • $12.50Sandwich, Pickle Spear & Cold Side Salad

Double Cheese Grilled Panini

The Cheese Shoppe has ya covered - Choose one OR two Cheeses - Cheesy Heaven!

  • $8.25Sandwich, Pickle Spear
  • $10.50Sandwich, Pickle Spear & Cold Side Salad

The Italian Cheese Melt - A Fan Favorite!

The perfect blend of Troyer Ham Off the Bone, Hard Salami & Pepperoni paired with your Cheese & Bread choice - we recommend Hot Pepper Cheese with Sourdough! Finished with Pepperoncinis & a splash of Italian Dressing!

  • $10.25Sandwich, Pickle Spear
  • $12.50Sandwich, Pickle Spear & Cold Side Salad

Classic Deli Sandwiches

Featuring Troyer’s Amish Meats & Cheeses!

Create Your Own Signature Sandwich with Your Choice of Bread, Cheese, Veggies & Condiments!

Available Cold or with Toasted Bread

Sandwich Options:

  • Breads: Tuscan White, Marble Rye, Sourdough, Pumpernickel or Wrap
  • Cheeses: American, Cooper (Sharp American), Sharp or Mild Cheddar, Provolone, Baby Swiss, Aged Swiss, Lacey Baby Swiss, Amish Butter, Muenster, Green Onion, Bruschetta Jack, Hot Pepper, Desert Fire.
  • Condiments: Duke’s Mayo, Yellow, Dijon, Honey & Spicy Mustard, Pink Salt or Black Pepper
  • Veggies: Lettuce, Tomatoes, Pickles, Onions, Pepperoncinis, Jalapeños or Banana Peppers
  • Dressings: Italian, Balsamic, Oil & Vinegar, Raspberry Vinaigrette, Ranch or Thousand Island
  • Premium Aiolis: Jalapeño, Pesto, Everything or Bacon - an excellent add on - .50¢
  • Cold Side Salads: Southern Amish Potato Salad, Southern Macaroni Salad or Amish-Style Cole Slaw

Add a bag of Kettle Chips to any sandwich order for $1.49 – all flavors!

Italian Cold Cut

Troyer Ham, Hard Salami & Pepperoni layered

  • $9.75Sandwich, Pickle Spear
  • $12.00Sandwich, Pickle Spear & Cold Side Salad

Turkey & Cheese

Troyer Turkey sliced thin with your choice of cheese.

  • $9.25Sandwich, Pickle Spear
  • $11.50Sandwich, Pickle Spear & Cold Side Salad

Ham & Cheese

Delicious Ham Off the Bone with your choice of cheese.

  • $9.25Sandwich, Pickle Spear
  • $11.50Sandwich, Pickle Spear & Cold Side Salad

All American Beef Bologna & Cheese

1959 Troyer Beef Bologna sliced thin with Cheese.

  • $9.50Sandwich, Pickle Spear
  • $11.75Sandwich, Pickle Spear & Cold Side Salad

Cheese & Veggie

Incredible Amish Cheeses with your choice of veggies.

  • $8.75Sandwich, Pickle Spear
  • $10.75Sandwich, Pickle Spear & Cold Side Salad

Salads

Our Gourmet Sandwiches Turned into A Fresh Salad!

Choose Your Salad Type, Cheese & Dressing - All on a Bed of Fresh Mixed Greens

Salad Options:

  • Cheeses: American, Cooper (Sharp American), Sharp or Mild Cheddar, Provolone, Baby Swiss, Aged Swiss, Lacey Baby Swiss, Amish Butter, Muenster, Green Onion, Bruschetta Jack, Hot Pepper, Desert Fire or Habanero-Jalapeño
  • Veggies: Cucumbers, Shredded Carrots, Black Olives, Jalapenos, Onions or Pickles
  • Dressings: Balsamic Vinaigrette, Red Wine Vinaigrette, Oil & Vinegar, Raspberry Walnut, Vinaigrette, Italian, Country French, Thousand Island, Ranch or Blue Cheese

$11.25

Italian Cheese Salad

Ham, Salami, Pepperoni & your choice of cheese.


$11.25

Ham & Cheese Salad


$11.25

Turkey & Cheese Salad


$11.25

Turkey & Ham & Cheese Combo Salad


$10.00

Cheese & Veggie Only - A Meatless Salad


$12.25

The Reuben Salad - with Corned Beef

We turn this classic deli sandwiches into a gourmet salad - Sauerkraut & all!  


$12.25

The Rachel Salad - with Pastrami

We turn this classic deli sandwiches into a gourmet salad - Sauerkraut & all!  


Awesome Grilled Hot & Sausage Dogs

Topping Options: Have it Your Way!

  • Sauerkraut: .75¢ or Cole Slaw: $1.00 or Hot Slaw: $1.50
  • Condiments: Ketchup, Yellow Mustard, Spicy Mustard, Relish - Sweet or Dill or Chopped Onions
  • Premium Toppings - .35¢ each: Southern Chow Chow, Corn Relish or Jalapeños

$4.00

Nathan’s All Beef Jumbo

  • $6.00with Chili
  • $6.50with Chili & Cheese

$4.00

Nathan’s All Beef Jalapeño & Cheese Dog

The Jalapeño & Cheese are inside the Dog

  • $6.00with Chili
  • $6.50with Chili & Cheese

$5.00

The Bahama Mama

A jumbo German Sausage - spiced just right.

  • $7.00with Chili
  • $7.50with Chili & Cheese

$6.00

Footlong Hot Dog

Direct from Michigan! Winter’s Brand Natural Casing!

  • $8.00with Chili
  • $8.50with Chili & Cheese

Cheese Shoppe Specialty Sandwiches

Our Premium Corned Beef & Pastrami Makes These First Three Classics Even Better!

The Reuben

Corned Beef, Swiss Cheese, Sauerkraut with Thousand Island Dressing on Marble Rye - toasted or pressed. 

  • $10.25Sandwich, Pickle Spear
  • $12.50Sandwich, Pickle Spear & Cold Side Salad

The Rachel

Pastrami, Swiss Cheese, Sauerkraut with Thousand Island Dressing on Marble Rye - toasted or pressed.

  • $10.25Sandwich, Pickle Spear
  • $12.50Sandwich, Pickle Spear & Cold Side Salad

Jewish Po’ Boy

A Blend of Pastrami, Corned Beef, Swiss Cheese, Sauerkraut & Thousand Island pressed on Marble Rye or Pumpernickel.

  • $10.25Sandwich, Pickle Spear
  • $12.50Sandwich, Pickle Spear & Cold Side Salad

The "LW" Cuban

Ham, Shredded Roasted Pork, Swiss Cheese, Mojo Mayo, Mustard & Dill Pickles - pressed on 8-Inch Hoagie.

  • $10.25Sandwich, Pickle Spear
  • $12.50Sandwich, Pickle Spear & Cold Side Salad

Spicy Italian Ciabatta Panini

Ham Off the Bone, Salami, Pepperoni, Hot Pepper Cheese, Mayo, Mustard & Pepperoncinis with Italian Dressing.

  • $10.25Sandwich, Pickle Spear
  • $12.50Sandwich, Pickle Spear & Cold Side Salad

Roast Beef ’N Cheddar Ciabatta

Our tender, rare Roast Beef & Cheddar Cheese - Cold or Panini Style. Comes with Lettuce, Tomato, Pickle and drizzled with a Premium Aioli Sauce - Everything Aioli recommended.

(Try with horseradish cheddar!)

  • $11.50Sandwich, Pickle Spear
  • $13.50Sandwich, Pickle Spear & Cold Side Salad

Soups

Fresh Hot Soup Can Soothe the Soul!

Beef & Bean Chili

  • $4.99Small
  • $5.99Large
  • $0.50Add Cheese

Soup of the Day

Rotation of Soups of the Day, including:

  • Chicken & Poblano Pepper
  • Chicken & Dumpling
  • Broccoli & Cheese

Beverages

A Variety of Bottled and Cans - Too Many to List Here...

Front Porch Teas & Lemonade

Made Right Here in Lake Wales at Florida’s Natural


Gourmet Classic Sodas

Hanks, Jones & Frostie Brand, Root Beers, Cream Sodas & Birch Beer


Other Options

Bottled Water & Pepsi Products


Shopping Cart

×

Your cart is empty.